Tim Southee, the captain of the New Zealand national cricket team, faces an uncertain future in the role after a heartbreaking three-wicket loss to Australia in the second Test at Christchurch. This defeat extends New Zealand’s winless streak against their trans-Tasman rivals to 13 Tests and their home series drought to a staggering 31 years.
Following the defeat, Southee acknowledged his own struggles with the ball, admitting he “had not taken the wickets he would have liked.” He finished the series with only four wickets, with younger pacers like Matt Henry, Ben Sears, and Will O’Rourke impressing more. Southee’s captaincy came under particular scrutiny during day four of the Christchurch Test, where his decision-making proved costly.
Bowling Choices and Selection Raise Eyebrows
Southee’s decision to delay introducing spin bowler Glenn Phillips until the final over before lunch on day four surprised many. By this time, Alex Carey and Mitchell Marsh had already reached their fifties and established a crucial 94-run partnership. Phillips, who had dismissed both Carey and Marsh earlier in the series, was a potential match-winner, and his delayed introduction raised questions about Southee’s tactics.
Southee defended his decision, stating, “We felt that seam was the option… We created a few chances through that first session.” However, his reasoning failed to convince all critics.
The selection of Scott Kuggeleijn, a specialist bowler who only bowled three overs in the second innings, also attracted criticism. While Kuggeleijn conceded only 10 runs off the bat, he conceded crucial extras, including four byes and six leg byes. Southee defended Kuggeleijn’s selection, highlighting his valuable contributions with the bat (40 runs) and his first-class record.
New Zealand’s fielding woes throughout the series also came under scrutiny. Critical catches were dropped in both Tests, with Rachin Ravindra’s dropped catch of Marsh in the second Test proving particularly costly. Southee, however, defended his players, stating, “Guys don’t mean to drop catches.”
Southee Unsure of Captaincy for Upcoming Tours
With a tour to the subcontinent later this year, featuring matches against Afghanistan, Sri Lanka, and India, Southee is unsure about retaining the captaincy. He acknowledged that “the make-up of the side changes slightly” on spin-dominated pitches, hinting that a spin-bowling specialist might be preferred as captain.
The defeat to Australia leaves New Zealand with plenty of questions to answer. Southee’s captaincy is under the microscope, and the team’s struggles against their old rivals in crunch moments remain a cause for concern. As they look ahead to tours in Asia, New Zealand must find solutions to improve their performance and emerge victorious in close encounters.
Stay updated with all the cricketing action, follow Cricadium on WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram
